Antigravity (Gemini 4 Carbon) built 2×–3× more experiments than any rival with the cleanest Firebase-ready ES module architecture.
1f7a9135-4696-4176-9bd0-b91c9ce970f9
One whimsical prompt.
Five miniature 3D worlds.
We gave Google Antigravity (Gemini 4 Carbon), ChatGPT Codex (GPT-6.2-Astra & GPT-6.1 Sol), Claude Fable 5.2, and Kimi K3.1 Pro the exact same open-ended prompt: build a cute, funny-named 3D traffic simulator busting everyday road myths. Play all five live below—and inspect where clean engineering, aesthetic taste, dual-renderer craft, and over-testing diverged.
6.1 Sol (`16:20`) nailed the cutest warm editorial UI (`6` labs); 6.2-Astra (`~13:00`) sculpted a rooftop-donut-shop town with baked WebP sprite fallbacks.
Claude Fable 5.2 (`35:00`) deployed straight to cloud with its signature right-hand side panel—but crammed CSS, UI, and 5 Three.js scenes into a single `.html` file.
Kimi K3.1 Pro spent the longest verifying UI & optimizing mesh triangles—yet cars ghost straight over each other in its roundabout and its speeding timer goes unread.
Test All Five 3D Simulators Live
Inside All Five Builds
Click any card’s Load on Stage or Fullscreen button to test its physics, camera controls, and UI ergonomics directly.
Under the Hood: Clean Modules, Baked Fallbacks, Monoliths & Bugs
Engineering Scorecard & Scenario Matrix
| Model & Harness | App Title | Build Time | Labs Built | Code Structure | Cloud & Assets | Design & Physics Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google Antigravity Gemini 4 Carbon (Medium) | BeepBeep BeanTown! | 16:00 | 13 Labs | 19 ES modules · 10,954 LOC (cleanest separation) | Firebase Hosting config ready; mobile needed +1 prompt | Most ambitious traffic science coverage; rock-solid roundabout & Braess physics |
| ChatGPT Codex GPT-6.2-Astra | Honk Hollow | ~13:00 | 4 Labs | 7 ES/CSS files · 1,081 LOC + baked WebP sprite fallback | OpenAI cloud + 3.46 MB offline single-file export; zero CDNs | Richest 3D town props (donut shop!), twin synchronized junction sims, fixed views |
| ChatGPT Codex GPT-6.1 Sol (Medium) | Jammy Little Roads | 16:20 | 6 Labs | 5 files · 404 LOC + `node --test` unit suite | Deployed to OpenAI cloud out of the box; responsive | Cutest & cleanest editorial UI; free-orbit cam, honest citations & clean IDM |
| Claude Fable 5.2 (Medium) | Jellybean Jam | 35:00 | 5 Labs | 1 monolithic `.html` · 609 lines (hard to maintain) | Deployed to Claude cloud out of the box; bottom-sheet mobile | Typical Claude side-panel look; fun 16× warp & Tailgating bonks |
| Kimi K3.1 Pro (Medium) | Bumper Buddies | 54:00 | 5 Labs | 4 ES modules · 2,412 LOC + Three.js chunk split | Local portable `dist/`; heavily tested responsive layout | Most QA & triangle optimization passes, yet roundabout & speeding physics failed |
| Traffic Scenario / Paradox | Tier | Antigravity (13) | GPT-6.2-Astra (4) | GPT-6.1 Sol (6) | Claude (5) | Kimi (5) |
|---|